






|
CEO's Corner
NAACLS Survey
by Olive M. Kimball, PhD, EdD Chief Executive Officer
|
CEO's Corner
By Olive M. Kimball, PhD, EdD
Chief Executive Officer
This was the second year during which, by means of an electronic survey, NAACLS
received the annual report from programs. This was independent of the survey
usually sent by the American Medical Association, the results of which are used
in the Health Profession Education Directory. Beginning in March of this year
NAACLS program directors were notified that the survey was coming. After the
survey went out email reminders were sent. These were followed by phone calls
and later by a very few "letters of last resort."
Table 1 shows the actual numbers of programs by level for 2003 and 2004. (From
the 2004 (last year) and 2005 (this year) surveys.)
Table 1 Program Numbers |
| Type |
2003 |
2004 |
| CA |
2 |
2 |
| CG |
5 |
5 |
| CLS/MT |
235 |
232 |
| CLT/MLT |
205 |
203 |
| DMS |
2 |
3 |
| HT |
25 |
25 |
| HTL |
2 |
2 |
| PATH A |
6 |
6 |
| PHLEB |
56 |
54 |
It can be seen that the numbers of programs have just about stabilized for the
two years. However this follows a dramatic shift in numbers of viable programs
for CLS/MT relative to 1994 when there were 383. From our current records, the
number of program closures this year for CLS/MT is 5 as opposed to 32 closures
in 1995, 24 in 1996 and 1997 and 24 again in 1999. While there has been a
dramatic decline in program numbers, there is now a tapering off of withdrawals.
For CLT/MLT programs the number of closures has also tapered off, for in 2005
there were three that closed in contrast to the peak in 2003 when 19 closed.
Meanwhile, there continue to be a few new programs starting up.
Looking at numbers of graduates we can see from Table 2 that CLS/MT graduates
increased in 2003 and 2004. However, they are still way below the numbers over
the last decade, for in 1995 there were 3,572 graduates. The peak number of CLS/MT
graduates occurred in the seventies when there were 6,519 graduates in 1977.
Despite the large number of program closures for CLT/MLT over the past ten years
(there were 259 active programs in 1995) new programs continue to be accredited
and the overall number of graduates is again increasing. It should be noted,
however, that nearly 1000 graduates are from military programs and few of these
graduates become certified and eventually go into non-military laboratories.
Therefore, the actual number of possible new hires for civilian clinical
laboratories is considerably less than 2000. Interestingly, last year programs
were asked for an estimate of the number of graduates they would have this year.
In most cases the numbers that actually graduated in 2004 were higher than
estimates.
Table 2 Graduate Numbers |
| Type |
2001 |
2002 |
2003 |
2004 |
| CA |
4 |
3 |
5 |
16 |
| CG |
30 |
35 |
38 |
36 |
| CLS/MT |
1894 |
1823 |
1923 |
1975 |
| CLT/MLT |
1817 |
1964 |
2143 |
2415 |
| DMS |
0 |
6 |
15 |
17 |
| HT |
111 |
164 |
193 |
200 |
| HTL |
9 |
8 |
5 |
16 |
| PATH A |
35 |
46 |
44 |
55 |
The number of histotechnician programs remains somewhat steady with very few
initials or closures. However, the number of graduates appears to be higher than
ever recorded with the average number of graduates per program now at seven or
eight. That indicates an upswing in interest and this was confirmed by one or
two histotechnician program directors on the survey who commented on an increase
in class size. The average number of graduates seems to be increasing for CLS/MT
as well and even more strikingly for phlebotomy. Several comments from CLS/MT
program directors indicated increased enrollment but for some the quality of
applicants is still an issue.
Attrition for programs varies considerably and there was apparently some
confusion on the part of responders to the survey. Some provided attrition
numbers over the entire program length and some by academic year. However,
pathologists' assistant and histotechnologist programs had less than one percent
of attrition for their programs but the overall attrition for a number of
programs increased over the past year. CLT/MLT attrition seems to continue to be
high (nearly 37 percent last year) and it was underscored by survey comments
that were included such as:
- Fewer applicants
- Decline in academic ability
- Students have too many other responsibilities while enrolled
A question on the survey asked about how difficult it was last year to find
program faculty. While several program directors noted they find it difficult to
recruit faculty with appropriate credentials for programs in a research
university, very few responded that they were actually searching. Comments like
"Have not had a reason to fill a position" or "I am the only full time faculty
member" were typical.
On another note related to faculty, there were several comments suggesting that
NAACLS should require specific educational and experiential requirements for
faculty to assure that administrators don't fill faculty positions
inappropriately. Still a few thought NAACLS was too prescriptive and/or should
make the accreditation or approval process less cumbersome.
Another question asked what percentage of graduates found jobs within six months
and/or went on to school. Only pathologists' assistant graduates all found jobs
within the specified time and none went directly on to additional education. For
DMS graduates, 92 percent found jobs within six months and eight percent went on
to school. Figures for CLS/MT, CLT/MLT, Cyto, HT and HTL graduates were between
70-80 percent with many going on for additional education. Phlebotomy and
clinical assistant graduates overall seemed to take the longest to find jobs but
follow-up data of these graduates may not have been as complete or they may have
been employed while in the educational program.
There seemed to be fewer technical challenges for program directors completing
the survey this year and staff were willing and able to assist with any apparent
problems. Respondents with older versions of Netscape reported problems getting
past page four. We are working to resolve this but also encourage program
directors to keep up to date with the free downloads of their web browsing
software.
We were pleased to receive many comments about the survey itself. A few examples
include:
Some critical but helpful:
Accreditation standards should be more stringent
Need separate survey designed for articulated programs
Survey concentrates too much on process
Survey appears geared towards 3+1 programs
Should be a 'don't know' in some categories (i.e. jobs, continuing ed.)
Some complementary:
The survey was short and easy to complete.
Thanks for making this so easy to fill out.
Nice survey! I found the survey to be user friendly; questions were easy to
understand.
I have found that the surveys are conducted in fair and professional manner.
We appreciate the helpful comments and invite additional thoughts as we plan for
the survey in spring of 2006. (Note: The Dr. NAACLS article in this issue of the
NAACLS News discusses how the survey data is used.)

|

|

|

|

|
|
|

|
|

|
|
A Coalition is Pushing for Phlebotomy Personnel Standards
by Dennis Ernst, MT (ASCP) Director, Center for Phlebotomy Education, Inc.
|
|

|
|
CEO's Corner
NAACLS Survey by Olive M. Kimball, PhD, EdD Chief Executive Officer
|
|

|
|
NAACLS is Studying Advanced Level CLS/MT
Lucy J. Randles, M.A., CLS/CLDDir
|
|

|
|
President's Report
by David D. Gale, PhD President, NAACLS Board of Directors
|

|
|
|

|
|

|
|
Combining Self Studies
by Marcia A. Armstrong, PhD, MT(ASCP), CLS(NCA) Chair, Programs Approval Review Committee
|

|
|
|

|
|

|
|
Dr. NAACLS
Advice for Accredited and Approved Programs
|
|
|

Copyright © 2008 National Accrediting Agency for Clinical Laboratory Sciences. All rights reserved.
Comments or suggestions to the site editor.
|